Web Wombat - the original Australian search engine
 
You are here: Home / Entertainment / DVDs / Reviews / The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada
Entertainment Menu
Business Links
Premium Links
Web Wombat Search
Advanced Search
Submit a Site
 
Search 30 million+ Australian web pages:
Try out our new Web Wombat advanced search (click here)
DVDs
Humour
Movies
TV
Books
Music
Theatre

 Three Burials
(Of Melquiades Estrada)

Buy Now
Review by Clint Morris

It’s long, vague, perplexing, striving and hasty – but don’t let a silly little thing like a ‘movie title’ put you off a perfectly good movie (though, I bet it does)

That's why The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada is now simply called Three Burials in Australia.

The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada

As non-conforming and singular as it’s director - Tommy Lee Jones, making his feature directorial debut, he directed a telemovie a few years back called “The Good Ol’ Boys” - but as brilliant too, Three Burials is the ultimate in anti-Hollywood: staggeringly unflashy, hugely character-driven, widely open to construal, and ultimately, agreeably real.

If mullet-haired Tom Hanks cracking puzzle books bored you, and if you thought Wolverine’s claws were too blunt, and Mission: Impossible just ‘too much Cruise’, then you’ll appreciate this one. It’s a solid film indeed. 

The performances are amazingly good; the locations are exquisite, and its messages – as inspiring as they are unexpected.

A whodunit-of-sorts, the film stars Jones as a ranch foreman honouring his late friend, illegal immigrant Melquiades (Julio César Cedillo), appeal to be buried in his native Mexico should he give up the ghost in Texas. Meantime, one of the new Border Patrol boys (Barry Pepper) is about to get to know the late man, a hell of a lot better.

As you’ll have worked out for yourself from my vague synopsis, I don’t want to give up too much about the film. Part of its appeal is letting the story unfold for itself.

As a director, Tommy Lee Jones is surprisingly proficient – showing both creativity and nous behind the lens, at times shooting sequences that would turn John Sayles or Sam Peckinpah to mush. He always puts the story before anything else (unlike a lot of the films he’s been in himself), and the film is better for it. He might have worked harder on the first act (the back-forward shift between ‘then’ and ‘now’ may be confusing to some viewers), might've humanised the villain a tad more, and possibly retained the same tone for the overall picture (in contrast to switching from thriller to black comedy, three quarters of the way through), but overall, it’s a terrific debut.

They don’t make ‘em like they used to – something Tommy Lee Jones obviously agrees with.

EXTRAS

The zone 4 DVD is actually pretty damn good, especially compared to the release that some of the other global DVD zones received. Among the extras are a making-of, a bit on the soundtrack, some interviews, plus deleted scenes, footage from the premiere and a commentary by Tommy Lee Jones, Dwight Yoakam and January Jones. 

The commentary track - often one of the best features of most DVDs - isn't the best; in fact it's a bit dull. There's too much dead-air between topics of conversation to really captivate you, and consequently, the trio have little to offer besides back-slapping each other on a "job well done".

Conclusion: Movie 75% Extras: 60%

Buy Now

Shopping for...
Visit The Mall

Promotion

Home | About Us | Advertise | Submit Site | Contact Us | Privacy | Terms of Use | Hot Links | OnlineNewspapers | Add Search to Your Site

Copyright © 1995-2012 WebWombat Pty Ltd. All rights reserved