Web Wombat - the original Australian search engine
 
You are here: Home / Entertainment / DVDs / Reviews / Carnivale: The Complete First Season
Entertainment Menu
Business Links
Premium Links
Web Wombat Search
Advanced Search
Submit a Site
 
Search 30 million+ Australian web pages:
Try out our new Web Wombat advanced search (click here)
DVDs
Humour
Movies
TV
Books
Music
Theatre

Carnivale: The Complete First Season

Review by Clint Morris

I’m usually plonked on top of that bandwagon that travels into "critically acclaimed but little seen" shows terrain.

I flew the flag for everything “Twin Peaks” in the early '90s, surrendered to the irresistible charm of “The Sopranos”, and even found myself watching Shaun Cassidy’s “American Gothic” for a while there.

Carnivale: The Complete First Season

Like a tightly-jammed Vegemite lid, “Carnivale” though, I just couldn’t get into – well, not as much as what I would’ve liked anyway.

An insolently odd, but stylistic series, “Carnivale” is set in Oklahoma, 1934, with young Ben Hawkins (Nick Stahl) joining a wacky travelling Circus, after the death of his mother. There, he comes face to face with a weird assortment of characters, including a mysterious futurist, bearded lady and pint-sized con artist (played no less by infamous “Twin Peaks” dwarf, Michael J.Anderson). Seems Hawkins might be wearing the ‘I am different’ shirt pretty soon too though, as he discovers he’s got a phenomenal, slightly disturbing super power.

The first season – 12 episodes- centre around the lady’s understanding of his gift, and how it ultimately has equally gifted Brother Justin Crowe (Clancy Brown), an evil preacher, looking in his direction.

“Carnivale” is a good show, a very good show, but if you’re anything like me, need something with a bit more kick in it, then you’ll be hard pressed trying to get through the set in one sitting. On the other hand, if you appreciate something novel, great costume design, and a reasonably entrancing story – then you might just ‘get into it’, and dribble for more.

The performances are a highlight. Clancy Brown and Nick Stahl are the standouts, but pint-sized Anderson and the other players making up the Carnivale gang are all quite stellar.

I’ll be back for the second season, just hoping there’s a little more gusto the tale and a little less characterisation next time.

“Carnivale” isn’t going to be everyone’s pint of lager, but chances are even those who don’t fall for it’s uniqueness at the outset, will at least find one element highly appreciable.

DVD Extras

Presented in 16:9 and Dolby Digital 5.1, “Carnivale” looks an absolute dream on DVD. Unfortunately, what this means is that less space is available and that’s why the few episodes of season one are spaced out over six discs.

In terms of extras, there are a couple of worthwhile things, but nothing worth bringing Private Ryan home for. There’s commentaries by the chaps that made the show on a couple of the episodes and an EPK style making-of. The commentaries are quite informative, but the making-of is filler, nothing more.

Conclusion: Movie 70% Extras 30%

Shopping for...
Visit The Mall

Promotion

Home | About Us | Advertise | Submit Site | Contact Us | Privacy | Terms of Use | Hot Links | OnlineNewspapers | Add Search to Your Site

Copyright © 1995-2013 WebWombat Pty Ltd. All rights reserved